The Herald ghanaThe Herald ghana
  • Home
  • General
  • Entertainment
  • Politics
  • Editorial
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Feature
  • Health
  • World
Reading: Court ruling on re-collation flawed
Share
Aa
The Herald ghanaThe Herald ghana
Aa
  • Home
  • General
  • Entertainment
  • Politics
  • Editorial
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Feature
  • Health
  • World
Search
  • Home
  • General
  • Entertainment
  • Politics
  • Editorial
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Feature
  • Health
  • World
Follow US
  • Advertise
Copyright © 2022 The Herald Ghana. All Rights Reserved
GeneralMajor 2

Court ruling on re-collation flawed

Published December 23, 2024 4 Min Read
Share
4 Min Read
SHARE

In every facet of life, a man is entitled to double fidelity, save in matters of the law .

The settled practice and the law requires that the challenge to a declaration of a winner in an election must be by way of a petition .

The recent disputes about election declarations must be reconciled against the settled practice.

It is my understanding that an EC officer spoke to duress as the basis for making a declaration in favor of a candidate. The side in whose favour the Declaration was made deny this factual allegation. In such a circumstance, there is a clear case of dispute on the facts or contested evidence for that matter.

The basic law teaches that in contested matters, the law does not admit of Judicial Review remedies, save in jurisdictional matters where evidence will be led on a collateral fact.

More Read

NDC/Tamale Central by-election

Recollation of Results: Accra High Court adjourns ruling on NDC’s objection to January 1

Supreme Court quashes results in Tema Central, Ablekuma North, Techiman South, Okaikwei Central

Under the circumstances, the grant of an Application for Judicial Review in an election dispute where allegations of duress are being contested is a flawed position.

It is respectfully submitted, by way of an example that, in an instance where a Judge gives a Judgment without taking into account some aspects of the evidence, the remedy is an Appeal and not Judicial Review.

The situation, in my view, is no different from the situation where a Declaration is made without taking into consideration the entirety of the “pink sheets” .

The allegation of duress by the EC Officer is one that has hints of criminality, and thus, the Court will reach a decision on same on a slight scale above the balance of probabilities in civil proceedings.

It is for the EC, which alleges “duress” to come before the Court to raise the issue, and not the other way round.

Yesterday’s proceedings were flawed. The other interested persons were not made parties to the process. This was a clear breach of natural justice .

It is necessary that the Courts and lawyers walk the settled path in such contentious matters .

At the root of this Mandamus Applications is an attack on purported Declarations. To that end, the most fundamental flaw in all of these matters is that the Applicants do not have a cause of action for the declarations are ineffective, unless Gazetted.

The law makes room for aggrieved parties to complain, and thus, a party can make or pray for remedies in respect of processes leading to the Declaration. In such a case, a party can ask for an Order directed at the EC to act in accordance with the CI 127 .

However, once a Declaration is made, it merges into the common law. The aggrieved party must wait for his or her cause of action to accrue. There is no good in delivering premature Judgment.

Finally, I draw the reader’s attention to Order 55 rule (5) 3 of CI 47 which gives a Respondent to an Application for Judicial Review a settled time period of not less than 7 days to respond. This Application was filed on the 17th of Dec 2024 and heard on 20th. That was extremely “curious”.

In the absence of an Application to Abridge the time, the Court had no jurisdiction to have heard this Application. .

By Kwame Boafo Akuffo Esq
Box 99
Akropong Akwapim

You Might Also Like

Recollation of Results: Accra High Court adjourns ruling on NDC’s objection to January 1

Supreme Court quashes results in Tema Central, Ablekuma North, Techiman South, Okaikwei Central

razak.bawa December 23, 2024
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Whatsapp Copy Link
What do you think?
Love0
Sad0
Cry0
Happy0
Surprise0
Angry0
Wink0
Previous Article NDC accuses Jean Mensa, others of illegality & impunity
Next Article EC’s ‘illegal redeclarations’ must be challenged in court – Srem Sai

Stay Connected

Facebook Like
Twitter Follow
Instagram Follow
Youtube Subscribe
- Advertisement -
Ad imageAd image

Latest News

court hammer/coup/marriage
Court of Appeal upholds life sentence for Jirapa Dubai hotel murder convict
General Major 4 November 19, 2026
Tottenham man arrested in Dublin over fatal stabbing of 21-year-old in North London
General Major 2 November 19, 2026
Emirates tops Time’s inaugural World’s Best Airlines 2027 rankings
Business Major 2 November 19, 2026
South Africa: Alex Dadey champions intergenerational African businesses, technology and regional partnerships at CNBC Africa Forum
Business Major 1 November 19, 2026
CurrencyRate

You Might also Like

NDC/Tamale Central by-election
Major 1Major Politics

Recollation of Results: Accra High Court adjourns ruling on NDC’s objection to January 1

December 31, 2024
GeneralMajor 1

Supreme Court quashes results in Tema Central, Ablekuma North, Techiman South, Okaikwei Central

December 27, 2024

Copyright © 2022-2025 The Herald Ghana. All Rights Reserved

Removed from reading list

Undo
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?