The Herald ghanaThe Herald ghana
  • Home
  • General
  • Entertainment
  • Politics
  • Editorial
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Feature
  • Health
  • World
Reading: IMF faces internal attack over flaws in biggest bailouts
Share
Aa
The Herald ghanaThe Herald ghana
Aa
  • Home
  • General
  • Entertainment
  • Politics
  • Editorial
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Feature
  • Health
  • World
Search
  • Home
  • General
  • Entertainment
  • Politics
  • Editorial
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Feature
  • Health
  • World
Follow US
  • Advertise
Copyright © 2022 The Herald Ghana. All Rights Reserved
BusinessMajor 2

IMF faces internal attack over flaws in biggest bailouts

Published January 10, 2025 6 Min Read
Share
6 Min Read
SHARE

The IMF’s in-house watchdog has criticised the fund over a lack of consistency in some of its biggest bailouts of the past two decades, calling on officials to address claims they succumb to political pressures to back big, risky repeat borrowers.

Rules for outsized loans to countries such as Argentina, Ukraine and Egypt needed an overhaul as “perceptions of a lack of even-handedness” were affecting the fund’s credibility, the IMF’s independent evaluation office said in a report on Thursday.

The report casts light on one of the thorniest issues facing the IMF, as the Washington-based institution comes under pressure to balance mounting debt problems in more and more developing economies with the taxing of its resources by a small group of countries that it is struggling to wean off its support.

The fund’s biggest lending commitment is to Argentina, where President Javier Milei is seeking a new $10bn loan, on top of $44bn the country tapped since 2018 under the exceptional access rules. The country’s obligations to the IMF are so large that last year it tapped a renminbi swap line with the Chinese central bank to help repayments.

Ongoing IMF support for Ukraine is also a linchpin of Kyiv’s financing of its war effort against Russia’s invasion, while a fund loan to Egypt this year was seen as stabilising a key economy on the frontline of fallout from the Gaza war.

More Read

Julie Kozack/IMF/PURC/Tariff hike/electricity

IMF says Ghana reaping benefits of difficult economic reforms

IMF outlines eight priorities for Ghana after first PCI review
Mahama tells GoldBod to stay course despite IMF concerns – Gyamfi
Ato Forson predicts Ghana’s economy will beat IMF’s 5.7% growth forecast

Kristalina Georgieva, the IMF managing director, said in response to the assessment that a fund review of the rules governing its biggest bailouts was “needed to ensure that the policy remains fit for purpose in an evolving global context”.

But she cautioned that the IMF still needs space for flexibility and that too many sweeping reservations about its commitments to countries such as Argentina and Ukraine could backfire, and weaken countries’ ability to return to markets.

The fund introduced a so-called “exceptional access policy” in 2002 to better regulate large bailouts that put bigger risks on IMF resources.

While the watchdog acknowledged the fund’s policy for so-called “exceptional access” cases, where a country borrows many times more than usual limits, has worked better than previous use of discretion, it “has not provided a substantively higher standard” compared to normal bailouts, the office said.

“The use of the [policy] at times may have led to delaying debt resolution problems and it has not catalysed private financing to the extent the fund envisaged when it was adopted,” it added

Under a long-standing policy, countries have had to pay surcharges, or extra interest, on IMF lending above a set quota, in order to discourage large repeat borrowings. The fund reformed the surcharges this year, including a cut to the rate.

“Outside the fund, there is a strong perception of political pressures in some high-profile cases affecting the assessment” of bailouts under the exceptional access rules, the IEO said.

The IMF often faces criticism that it bows to big shareholders that often are also large lenders to countries in trouble.

In October, Brent Neiman, the US Treasury Assistant Secretary for International Finance, said the fund needed to be firmer in assessing bailouts where China was a big creditor.

The IEO report said its evaluation “confirms that pressures on staff and management, exerted directly or indirectly, were strong in high-stakes cases”.

The review did not find evidence that confirmed concerns that economic assumptions behind bailouts were “reverse-engineered” in order to get loans approved.

But it identified weaknesses in processes, such as when the IMF relied on political assurances ahead of elections that bailout conditions such as big spending cuts will be delivered.

It added that the fund also tended to wrongly assume that big bailouts would boost investor confidence in countries. “The expected confidence effects relied more on assumption than on analytical explanation,” the report said

The assessment reviewed cases from 2002 up to the middle of last year, such as the IMF’s bailout of Greece at the start of the Eurozone crisis in 2010, and a 2015 loan to Ukraine after Russia annexed Crimea.

It also looked at so-called “grey zone” cases where the fund judges that a country’s debts are sustainable before it lends but cannot say so with high probability.

For grey zone cases in particular, Georgieva said “further reflection and review based on more recent data” was useful.

“We do not want to increase the risk of inadvertently raising prospects of deeper debt restructurings and increased losses,” Georgieva said.

You Might Also Like

IMF says Ghana reaping benefits of difficult economic reforms

IMF outlines eight priorities for Ghana after first PCI review

Mahama tells GoldBod to stay course despite IMF concerns – Gyamfi

Ato Forson predicts Ghana’s economy will beat IMF’s 5.7% growth forecast

razak.bawa January 10, 2025
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Whatsapp Copy Link
What do you think?
Love0
Sad0
Cry0
Happy0
Surprise0
Angry0
Wink0
Previous Article The Grand National Hotel by Saint Peter, Sydney, opens Jan 31 2025
Next Article Ranking Member Shaheen calls for accountability and global action following genocide determination in Sudan

Stay Connected

Facebook Like
Twitter Follow
Instagram Follow
Youtube Subscribe
- Advertisement -
Ad imageAd image

Latest News

court hammer/coup/marriage
Court of Appeal upholds life sentence for Jirapa Dubai hotel murder convict
General Major 4 November 19, 2026
Tottenham man arrested in Dublin over fatal stabbing of 21-year-old in North London
General Major 2 November 19, 2026
Emirates tops Time’s inaugural World’s Best Airlines 2027 rankings
Business Major 2 November 19, 2026
South Africa: Alex Dadey champions intergenerational African businesses, technology and regional partnerships at CNBC Africa Forum
Business Major 1 November 19, 2026
CurrencyRate

You Might also Like

Julie Kozack/IMF/PURC/Tariff hike/electricity
BusinessMajor 4

IMF says Ghana reaping benefits of difficult economic reforms

November 16, 2026
IMF
GeneralMajor 2

IMF outlines eight priorities for Ghana after first PCI review

November 5, 2026
BusinessMajor 2

Mahama tells GoldBod to stay course despite IMF concerns – Gyamfi

October 20, 2026
BusinessMajor 1

Ato Forson predicts Ghana’s economy will beat IMF’s 5.7% growth forecast

October 15, 2026
Show More

Copyright © 2022-2025 The Herald Ghana. All Rights Reserved

Removed from reading list

Undo
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?