By Dr Mohammed Ibn Mukhtar
Tegbo Company Ltd.
ibnmukta@gmail.com
As a typical feature of the Fourth Republic of Ghana Judiciary, the recent public comments by Ghana’s Chief Justice have sparked yet another vigorous debate across the country. It has been the norm that some citizens praised the remarks as an honest assessment of governance performance. Others questioned whether such comments were appropriate for the head of the Judiciary.
Reasonable people may disagree about the remarks themselves. However, the controversy raises a much bigger question for Ghana’s democracy which is the concern of this article:
How important is neutrality in public institutions?
The answer is simple. Neutrality is not merely a matter of etiquette. It is one of the foundations upon which public trust in democratic institutions rests.
In every democracy, citizens depend on institutions that must serve everyone, regardless of political affiliation. Courts, electoral commissions, audit institutions, anti-corruption agencies, security services, and the civil service all perform functions that require public confidence.
Unlike politicians who derive their authority from elections, many state institutions derive their authority from trust.
The Judiciary provides perhaps the clearest example. Courts do not command armies. Judges do not contest elections. The power of the courts rests largely on the willingness of citizens to accept judicial decisions, including decisions they may disagree with. Such acceptance becomes possible only when people believe judges are independent, impartial, and above partisan politics.
This is why public perceptions matter.
A court may be completely independent in reality, yet public confidence can still be weakened if citizens begin to question its neutrality. In democratic governance, legitimacy depends not only on what institutions do but also on how they are perceived.
This principle extends beyond the Judiciary.
Across the public sector, citizens expect officials to exercise power fairly and professionally. Whether it is a civil servant processing applications, a police officer enforcing the law, an electoral commissioner supervising elections, or a regulator overseeing public resources, public confidence depends on the belief that decisions are being made according to law and professional standards rather than political allegiance.
Ghana’s 1992 Constitution does not expressly establish neutrality as a comprehensive constitutional doctrine. Nevertheless, many constitutional provisions point in that direction. The Constitution emphasizes fairness, accountability, objectivity, integrity, and the rule of law. Together, these values create an expectation that public authority will be exercised in the public interest rather than for partisan advantage.
That expectation is crucial for democratic stability.
One of Ghana’s greatest democratic achievements under the Fourth Republic has been the peaceful transfer of power between competing political parties. These transitions have succeeded not simply because elections are held regularly but because key institutions have generally retained sufficient public credibility to manage political competition within constitutional boundaries.
Trust capital is therefore a key democratic asset.
When citizens trust public institutions, they are more likely to obey court decisions, accept election outcomes, cooperate with public authorities, and resolve disputes peacefully. When that trust declines, even lawful decisions can become the subject of suspicion and controversy.
The experiences of other democracies reinforce this lesson.
Countries such as the United Kingdom, Canada, South Africa, and the United States all place considerable emphasis on judicial conduct and public communication. While approaches differ, a common theme emerges which is that public confidence in institutions is too valuable to be taken for granted.
This does not mean that judges, public servants, or heads of independent institutions should remain silent. Democratic governance requires institutions to defend constitutional principles, uphold the rule of law, and engage the public when necessary.
Neutrality should never be confused with silence.
Rather, neutrality means exercising authority and communicating in ways that preserve confidence that decisions are based on law, evidence, and professional judgment rather than partisan preferences.
For institutions whose legitimacy depends heavily on public trust, both reality and appearance matter.
As Ghana continues its democratic journey, this lesson deserves attention. The strength of a democracy is measured not only by elections and constitutional provisions but also by the credibility of the institutions that serve its citizens.
Public trust or trust capital is difficult to build and easy to lose.
That is why neutrality remains more than an ethical ideal. It is a democratic safeguard. It helps protect institutional legitimacy, strengthens confidence in governance, and reassures citizens that public authority is being exercised for the common good rather than partisan interests.
The debate surrounding the Chief Justice’s remarks will eventually fade. But the larger governance question it has raised will remain.
How do we preserve trust in the institutions that hold our democracy together?
The answer begins with neutrality.




