…..As Gary Nimako decamps
The Herald, has gathered reports of deepening divisions within the opposition New Patriotic Party (NPP) over the dismissal of Justice Gertrude Torkornoo.
While some within the Party argue that it is time to move on from the controversy, others insist that the NPP must rally behind the former Chief Justice and support her in any action she chooses to take against the John Mahama administration, viewing it as an opportunity to score political points.
Among those who believe the Party has done enough is Gary Nimako, the NPP’s Director of Legal Affairs. He is said to have deliberately refrained from public commentary on the matter to avoid heightening tensions within the Party and among its supporters.
However, prominent figures such as Minority Leader Alexander Kwamena Afenyo-Markin, National Organiser Henry Nana Boakye, General Secretary Justin Kodua Frimpong, and Vincent Ekow Asafuah are reportedly of the view that the Party must stand firmly with Justice Torkornoo to the end. They claim her removal forms part of an alleged attempt by President Mahama to “take control of the judiciary.”
Sources within the NPP suggest that Gary Nimako’s silence stems from privileged information and his involvement in specific behind-the-scenes engagements related to the case. His discretion, according to some insiders, is seen as a tactical move to avoid further internal conflict as the Party weighs its next steps.
The Herald understands that the disagreement has created unease within the NPP’s leadership, with senior figures divided over whether to confront the government publicly on the issue or to focus on rebuilding the Party’s image ahead of the next general elections.
On Monday, the opposition raised strong objections to the vetting of Justice Paul Baffoe-Bonnie for the position of Chief Justice, describing the move as a threat to Ghana’s constitutional order and judicial independence.
In a statement signed by the party’s General Secretary, Justin Kodua Frimpong, said, “The NPP will witness this travesty, strongly condemn it, and publicly denounce its outcome. The Constitution is the sacred covenant of the Ghanaian people, and we shall never relent in our duty to defend it.”
The NPP said the nomination by the Mahama administration constitutes a “grave breach of constitutional order,” given that the removal of former Chief Justice Gertrude Torkornoo is still the subject of multiple court cases.
According to the statement, there are seven substantive legal suits currently pending before the Supreme Court, the High Court, and the ECOWAS Court of Justice, challenging the legality and procedure surrounding Justice Torkornoo’s removal.
“It is a cardinal principle of constitutional governance that where the legitimacy of a foundational state action is directly challenged before a competent court, the political branches must exercise restraint until the judiciary has discharged its constitutional mandate,” the statement said.
The NPP further accused the government of showing disregard for judicial due process, warning that proceeding with a new appointment constitutes “a pre-emptive assault on the judicial function.”
The party also raised concerns about what it described as a conflict of interest on the part of the nominee, claiming that Justice Baffoe-Bonnie had previously presided over a case, Assafuah v. Attorney-General, which directly related to the status of the Chief Justice’s office.
“This situation engages the timeless principle of nemo judex in causa sua—that no person shall be a judge in their own cause,” the NPP stated, adding that his involvement and subsequent acceptance of the nomination undermine public confidence in the judiciary.
While acknowledging Justice Baffoe-Bonnie’s long service on the bench, the NPP described his acceptance of the nomination as “a gross and detrimental failure of judicial leadership.”
The party also cautioned the Mahama administration against using political power to undermine constitutional principles, saying, “Political majorities are transient, but constitutional principles are eternal.”
The NPP concluded by reaffirming its commitment to defend Ghana’s constitutional democracy and urged all citizens to stand up in defense of the rule of law.
“The Constitution is the sacred covenant of the Ghanaian people, and we shall never relent in our duty to defend it,” the statement said.
Interestingly, the Majority Leader, Mr Mahama Ayariga, has formally lodged a complaint with the Speaker of Parliament against Minority Leader Afenyo-Markin, accusing him of acts of contempt of Parliament and breach of parliamentary privilege.
In his submission, Mr Ayariga urged the Speaker to refer the matter to the Privileges Committee of Parliament for investigation and possible sanctions should Mr Afenyo-Markin be found culpable.
The Majority Leader cited Order 30 and Order 31(O) of the Standing Orders of Parliament, which outlined acts that constituted contempt of Parliament.
Giving the basis of his complaint, Mr Ayariga, who is the Leader of Government Business, explained that on July 22, 2025, the Parliament of Ghana passed a resolution, constituting Ghana’s delegation to the ECOWAS Parliament, explicitly removing Mr Afenyo-Markin’s name from the list.
The resolution, he said, was communicated to ECOWAS Parliament.
However, Mr Ayariga said, during the ECOWAS Parliament session held in Port Harcourt, Nigeria, from September 25–28, 2025, Ghana’s delegation encountered Mr Afenyo-Markin seated among members of Ghana’s delegation, despite his removal.
His presence reportedly caused ECOWAS Parliament to initially refuse to swear in the Ghana’s delegation, Mr Ayariga stated.
Mr Ayariga, also Member of Parliament for Bawku Central, recounted that he had to personally intervene and threatened Ghana’s withdrawal from ECOWAS before the Speaker of the ECOWAS Parliament eventually swore in four members of Ghana’s delegation.
Mr Ayariga stressed that Mr Afenyo-Markin’s attendance at the ECOWAS session was in “clear defiance” of Parliament’s resolution, thereby undermining the authority of the House.
“By defying this Parliament’s resolution and actually going to Port Harcourt to attend the session, he has affronted the dignity and engaged in an act that constitutes an affront to the authority of this Parliament,” Mr Ayariga emphasised.
According to Mr Ayariga, contempt included obstructing or impeding Parliament in the performance of its functions, obstructing, or impeding the Speaker, a Member, or an Officer of Parliament in the discharge of their duties and affronting the dignity or authority of Parliament and bringing the name of Parliament into disrepute.
The legislator argued that Mr Afenyo-Markin’s actions fell squarely within these provisions and urged the Speaker to refer the Minority Leader to the Privileges Committee for processing.
The Majority Leader insisted that appropriate sanctions be applied if the Committee found Mr Afenyo-Markin culpable.
Speaker Bagbin said he would diligently examine the merits of the complaint and take a decision on it.




