….Amid costs and ICUMS duplication claims
Documents in circulation amongst stakeholders and sighted by The Herald, have reignited debate over Ghana’s cargo-tracking policy.
This is after it emerged that a renewed push for Advance Cargo Information (ACI) and related cargo-manifest systems bears notable similarities to a Cargo Tracking Note (CTN) policy suspended by the Presidency in 2018 over concerns about duplication and increased costs to businesses.
The renewed discussion, follows reports that two separate private-sector interests are seeking to introduce cargo information systems into Ghana’s international trade framework.
One proposal is linked to Inter-Ocean Maritime and Logistics Institute Limited, which is associated with Electronic Cargo Tracking Note (ECTN) and Smart Port Note (SPN) technologies. The other comes from Rock Africa, which has presented an Advance Cargo Information proposal involving CargoX, TradeWindow, TradeXchange and FX3D.
Although both initiatives are being promoted as tools for revenue protection, trade intelligence, foreign exchange assurance, and customs risk management, some stakeholders within the trade sector argue that they closely resemble the CTN regime, which was halted eight years ago by the Akufo-Addo administration.
At the centre of the current debate is a letter dated 16 February 2018 from the Office of the President at Flagstaff House to the Commissioner-General of the Ghana Revenue Authority (GRA).
The letter, titled “Suspension of the Implementation of the Cargo Tracking Note”, followed a meeting held on 14 February 2018 involving the Association of Ghana Industries and the GRA, chaired by the Vice-President, Dr Mahamudu Bawumia.
According to the directive, the introduction of the CTN was to be suspended because the information required under the scheme was already available through cargo manifests covering imports into Ghana.
The Presidency further directed that manifest information should instead be made available during both the pre-arrival and arrival stages of customs clearance to ensure effective controls and validation of declaration data.
The letter also warned that implementing the CTN would increase the cost of doing business at Ghana’s ports and would be inconsistent with the government’s objective of making Ghana the most business-friendly nation in Africa.
That decision has now resurfaced as stakeholders assess the implications of new ACI, ECTN and SPN-type proposals.
A policy document reviewed by this newspaper argues that the financial impact of ACI schemes extends beyond a simple transaction charge and could result in “serious downstream economic consequences for Ghanaian importers and consumers”.
According to the document, ACI-related charges are typically not absorbed by foreign exporters but are instead passed along the supply chain to importers and, ultimately, consumers.
The document further suggests that a Smart Port Note arrangement could cost Ghanaian shippers tens of millions of US dollars annually when applied across prevailing container and general cargo traffic volumes.
The concern centres on the cumulative effect of additional charges within an already costly port environment.
Importers currently bear a range of expenses, including customs duties, statutory levies, port charges, shipping line fees, terminal handling costs and inspection-related charges. Critics argue that any new mandatory fee, however modest at the transaction level, could become substantial when applied across national import volumes.
They further contend that the additional costs would inevitably be reflected in the prices of imported goods, including food, pharmaceuticals, construction materials, machinery, spare parts and household products.
Questions have also been raised about potential duplication of existing systems.
Ghana already operates the Integrated Customs Management System (ICUMS), which functions as the country’s national single window for customs clearance and related trade processes.
A technical note reviewed by this newspaper questions whether a third-party provider is necessary to supply advance manifest information when ICUMS already performs that function.
The note states that manifests for cargo transported by sea, air and road are electronically transmitted through ICUMS. It also notes that permits, licences and exemption letters are issued electronically through the platform.
According to the document, all Ministries, Departments and Agencies involved in cross-border trade conduct their processes within ICUMS, enabling them to work from a shared set of documents and data.
The note further highlights that ICUMS includes a built-in Single Window feature that allows users to upload supporting documentation electronically at any stage of the customs clearance process.
The revived proposals have also prompted debate over customs valuation.
The technical note argues that Ghana has already achieved an end-to-end clearance system through ICUMS and that all available price verification sources are accessible to Customs via the platform. It therefore questions the need to introduce a secondary valuation mechanism.
Supporters of ACI, however, maintain that the system could strengthen early risk detection, improve revenue assurance and enhance trade intelligence.
A presentation by Rock Africa, reviewed by this newspaper, describes Advance Cargo Information as a system under which trade documentation is submitted and verified before cargo is loaded for shipment rather than after it arrives in Ghana.
The proposal identifies commercial invoices, bills of lading, packing lists, certificates of origin, and compliance certificates as documents to be verified before shipment.
According to the presentation, the system would help reduce under-invoicing and over-invoicing, improve duty collection and strengthen foreign exchange governance by providing the Bank of Ghana with document-backed visibility before foreign exchange allocations are made.
Rock Africa has also proposed a focused 60-day Proof of Concept involving between 20 and 50 import transactions, selected importers, selected banks and selected commodity groups.
The proposed pilot would include document uploads, CargoX verification, trade packet creation, ICUMS integration, duty assessment, foreign exchange verification and dashboard reporting.
Nevertheless, critics maintain that the 2018 presidential directive remains highly relevant because it addressed the same fundamental policy question now being debated: whether Ghana requires a separate CTN-style mechanism when manifest and customs information are already available within the existing clearance architecture.
The issue is expected to draw scrutiny from the Ministry of Transport, the Ministry of Trade and Industry, the Ghana Revenue Authority, the Ghana Shippers’ Authority, Ghana Link Network Services, Inter-Ocean Maritime and Logistics Institute Limited, Rock Africa, and other stakeholders.
Until clearer answers emerge, businesses are likely to continue asking whether Ghana is on the verge of reintroducing a policy that was previously suspended because it would increase the cost of doing business.




