The Managing Editor of The Herald, Larry Alans-Dogbey, has lodged an appeal at the Court of Appeal challenging his conviction and seven-day jail sentence for contempt of court, describing the ruling as flawed in law and an infringement on press freedom.
The appeal follows a High Court decision in Accra on June 25, 2026, presided over by Justice Isaac Addo, which found him guilty in proceedings linked to a defamation suit filed by businessman Kevin Okyere.
The case also involves Springfield Exploration and Production Limited, with Prime Mark Company Limited and Abdul Razak Bawa listed as co-defendants.
In his appeal filed on July 1, 2026, Alans-Dogbey argues that the High Court misapplied the law in enforcing an interlocutory injunction that restricted further publication on matters connected to the ongoing dispute.
He maintains that the order effectively operated as a prior restraint, preventing publication of material before the substantive defamation case had been heard and determined.
According to him, the court granted the injunction despite acknowledging that it was not making a determination on the merits of the main suit, thereby creating what he describes as a legally inconsistent position.
He further contends that the injunction was too broadly framed and incapable of objective enforcement, as it barred publications considered to “undermine and tarnish” the plaintiff’s reputation without clearly defining the scope of prohibited content.
The journalist argues that the wording of the order left room for subjective interpretation, making compliance uncertain and exposing him to contempt proceedings without clear legal guidance.
Alans-Dogbey also disputes the finding of malice, insisting the publications in question were grounded in official documents and credible sources, including EOCO correspondence, Ministry of Energy records, UK court documents and material obtained during cross-examination in related proceedings.
He faults the trial court for allegedly adopting an improper standard of proof, arguing that contempt proceedings require proof beyond reasonable doubt and not assumptions drawn from publication alone.
The appeal further claims that the burden of proof was wrongly shifted onto him to justify the accuracy of his reporting, instead of requiring the applicant to establish contempt.
It also argues that the publications were protected under constitutional guarantees on freedom of expression, particularly where reporting concerns matters of public interest such as Ghana’s oil and gas sector.
Alans-Dogbey challenges the reliance placed on the Supreme Court’s decision in the Montie FM contempt case, arguing that it involved threats against judicial officers and is therefore not comparable to reporting based on official records and court proceedings.
He also disputes the application of the sub judice principle, maintaining that the existence of a pending defamation suit does not automatically prohibit journalistic coverage of issues of public interest.
Among other grounds, the appeal alleges that the court failed to properly consider recognised journalistic defences, including fair comment, qualified privilege and fair and accurate reporting.
It further raises concerns about service of court processes, questioning the authenticity of a WhatsApp screenshot relied on as proof that documents were duly served.
On sentencing, he argues that the seven-day custodial term was disproportionate, especially given his long-standing career in journalism and constitutional protections for media practice, and says the court ought to have considered a non-custodial penalty.
He is asking the Court of Appeal to set aside both the conviction and sentence, quash the interlocutory injunction issued on June 11, 2025, and declare it void.




