Sean “Diddy” Combs’ legal team has moved to overturn the rapper’s federal conviction on prostitution-related charges, arguing that the activities in question constituted amateur pornography, which they claim is protected under the First Amendment.
The appeal, heard this week before a panel of judges at the Second Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals, challenges both the verdict and the 50-month prison sentence Combs is currently serving.
His lawyers argue that the trial judge erred by allowing conduct for which he was acquitted to influence sentencing, and that the punishment is disproportionately harsh compared with similar cases.
According to legal filings, Combs’ defence team maintains that the sexual encounters he organised were consensual and filmed, making them a form of expressive conduct rather than criminal prostitution.
“The First Amendment protects speech, including certain forms of sexual expression captured on camera,” the lawyers asserted.
Federal prosecutors, however, strongly reject the claim. They contend that transporting individuals for illegal sexual activity cannot be shielded by free speech rights, and warn that accepting such an argument would create a dangerous precedent, allowing prostitution networks to operate under the guise of “artistic expression.”
The case stems from a conviction under the Mann Act, which prohibits transporting individuals across state lines for the purpose of prostitution.
Combs was acquitted of more serious charges, including racketeering and sex trafficking, but found guilty on lesser counts related to moving escort sex workers between states.
The outcome of this appeal could reshape how First Amendment protections are interpreted in cases involving filmed sexual conduct.
Combs, who is not present for the appeal, is currently serving his sentence and is scheduled for release in 2028. His legal team remains confident that the appellate court could reduce or overturn the sentence, citing constitutional protections and judicial errors during the trial.




