Ghanaian legal scholar Prof Kwaku Asare has cautioned Chief Justice Paul Baffoe-Bonnie against public comments that could be perceived as partisan political assessments, following his remarks questioning Ghana’s performance over the past eight years.
Prof Asare said while he understood the sentiment behind the Chief Justice’s comments, the reference to “the past eight years” carried a clear political meaning within Ghana’s political discourse.
He argued that such language, particularly coming from the head of the Judiciary, could be interpreted as an assessment of one political administration against another and potentially undermine public confidence in judicial independence.
The Chief Justice made the remarks on Wednesday, 2 September, during a visit to the Minerals Income Investment Fund (MIIF), where he praised the performance of the institution and other state-owned entities.
Justice Baffoe-Bonnie said some of the developments he had witnessed during his visits had left him questioning what Ghana had been doing over the previous eight years.
“I must congratulate you. I mean, you have done marvellously well. See, because sometimes when we hear the things that you have done, the things that some organisations are doing now, we wonder; some of us keep wondering what really we have been doing in the past eight years,” he said.
He made similar observations after visiting the Social Security and National Insurance Trust (SSNIT), where he said he was impressed by what he had learnt about the institution’s performance.
The Chief Justice referred to previous plans to dispose of some SSNIT assets, including the Labadi Beach Hotel, and questioned how the country had reached such a position.
“If you compare that to the fact that not too long ago, SSNIT was preparing to sell its prized assets like Labadi Beach Hotel, you wonder how Ghana could have sunk so low,” he said.
Reacting in a Facebook post, Prof Asare said his concern was not whether the Chief Justice’s observations were accurate but the language used to express them.
“I understand the sentiment. But I worry about the language,” he wrote.
He said the phrase “the past eight years” had an unmistakable partisan connotation in Ghana’s political environment and could therefore be interpreted as a comparison between the records of different administrations.
“‘The past eight years’ carries an unmistakable partisan meaning in our political discourse. Coming from the Chief Justice, it can therefore easily be understood, fairly or unfairly, as an assessment of one administration relative to another,” Prof Asare said.
“That is territory the head of the Judiciary should avoid,” he added.
According to him, judges do not lose their status as citizens or their personal views when they assume judicial office, but the judicial robe imposes a greater responsibility for restraint in public pronouncements.
“Judges do not cease to be citizens when they assume office. But the robe necessarily constrains their public speech. This is especially so for the Chief Justice, whose words inevitably carry the institutional weight of the Judiciary,” he said.
Prof Asare also argued that the expectation of judicial restraint should be matched by an obligation on politicians to respect the independence of the Judiciary.
“We rightly insist that politicians respect judicial independence and stay out of the judicial arena. The obligation is reciprocal,” he said.
“Judges, particularly the Chief Justice, must also exercise the restraint necessary to stay out of the partisan political arena.”
He stressed that his criticism was not based on any assumption about the Chief Justice’s motives or the accuracy of his assessment of the performance of state institutions.
“The point is not whether the observation is right or wrong. Nor is it about the motives of the speaker. It is about protecting an institution,” Prof Asare said.
He warned that perceptions surrounding the Chief Justice’s political neutrality could become particularly important because cases involving decisions and actions of both the previous and current administrations could eventually come before the courts.
“There will be cases before our courts involving the acts and omissions of the previous government. There will be cases involving this government,” he said.
Prof Asare said no litigant should have reason to question whether the head of the Judiciary had already formed a favourable or unfavourable view of a particular administration.
“No litigant should have reason to wonder whether the head of the Judiciary has formed a favourable or unfavourable view of any administration,” he said.
He therefore maintained that judicial independence requires restraint from both politicians and judges when it comes to partisan politics.
“Judicial independence requires political restraint, from politicians toward judges, and from judges toward partisan politics,” Prof Asare said.
He concluded: “The higher the judicial office, the heavier the burden of restraint.”
Prof Asare’s comments come against the backdrop of the politically contentious circumstances surrounding Justice Baffoe-Bonnie’s elevation to the position of Chief Justice.
He became Acting Chief Justice in April 2025 after President John Dramani Mahama suspended then-Chief Justice Gertrude Torkornoo following the determination of a prima facie case against her under Article 146 of the Constitution.
Justice Baffoe-Bonnie, who was then the most senior Justice of the Supreme Court, assumed the acting position before President Mahama nominated him as substantive Chief Justice following Torkornoo’s removal.
Parliament subsequently approved his nomination by 163 votes to 69 in November 2025, following a contentious process during which the New Patriotic Party (NPP) Minority raised objections and boycotted his vetting.
The Minority argued, among other things, that the appointment should not proceed while legal challenges relating to Torkornoo’s removal were pending. It also raised concerns about Justice Baffoe-Bonnie’s involvement in Supreme Court proceedings connected to the removal process.
Justice Baffoe-Bonnie has rejected suggestions that his elevation was politically motivated. During his vetting, he defended his judicial record and pledged to uphold judicial independence and provide leadership capable of commanding confidence across the political divide.




